Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Eukaryotic Cell, December 2006, p. 2114-2119, Vol. 5, No. 12
1535-9778/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/EC.00059-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
,
Laboratory of Molecular Parasitology, The Rockefeller University, New York, New York
Received 24 February 2006/ Accepted 16 October 2006
|
|
|---|
20 subtelomeric expression sites (ES). VSG transcription is monoallelic, and little is known about the regulation of antigenic switching. To explore whether telomere length could affect antigenic switching, we created a telomerase-deficient cell line, in which telomeres shortened at a rate of 3 to 6 bp at each cell division. Upon reaching a critical length, short silent ES telomeres were stabilized by a telomerase-independent mechanism. The active ES telomere progressively shortened and frequently broke. Upon reaching a critical length, the short active ES telomere stabilized, but the transcribed VSG was gradually lost from the population and replaced by a new VSG through duplicative gene conversion. We propose a model in which subtelomeric-break-induced replication-mediated repair at a short ES telomere leads to duplicative gene conversion and expression of a new VSG. |
|
|---|
107 VSG. A large repertoire of VSG genes is dispersed among many subtelomeric regions, but the single transcribed copy is located in a telomeric expression site (ES) (6). T. brucei contains
20 similar ESs, and transcription occurs in a strictly monoallelic fashion (27, 37). An antigenic switch can be achieved by shifting transcription from one ES to another (in situ switch) (13), by a reciprocal translocation between two ESs (31), or when a previously silent VSG is copied into the active ES through duplicative gene conversion (24, 36). In pleomorphic wild-type strains, gene conversion-mediated switching predominates and occurs at a dramatically higher rate than in laboratory-adapted strains (29, 33, 34). Although we know a little about the molecular mechanisms underlying VSG switching, we do not know what precipitates switching events. In this study, we tried to determine whether telomere length could influence VSG switching. Human and T. brucei telomeres consist of long tracts of TTAGGG repeats and, together with their associated factors, they protect chromosome ends from nucleolytic degradation and illegitimate DNA repair activities (3, 5, 21, 38). In contrast to any other known organism, T. brucei telomeres grow at a steady rate of 7 to 9 bp per population doubling (PD), and the telomere adjacent to the single transcribed VSG gene in T. brucei undergoes frequent truncations (2, 13, 23, 28, 35), which are rapidly elongated by the telomerase (8, 10, 15). It remains unclear whether telomere truncations play a role in antigenic variation. Deletion of telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) from T. brucei causes progressive telomere shortening at a rate of 3 to 6 bp/PD, loss of minichromosomes, and genomic rearrangements among intermediate chromosomes (8, 9). At essential megabase chromosomes, silent ES telomeres stabilized within a discreet size range by a potentially novel telomerase-independent mechanism (8).
Here we report the consequences of telomere shortening at the actively transcribed VSG ES and propose a model for how this could precipitate a VSG switch.
|
|
|---|
DNA isolation, Southern blotting, and telomere size distribution analysis. Genomic DNA was isolated as previously described (22). Terminal restriction fragments containing specific VSG were detected by genomic blotting, hybridization, and phosphorimaging (14). By use of ImageQuant software, each lane in Fig. 1A was partitioned into 30 equally sized rectangles. The signal intensity in each rectangle was measured as a percentage of the total signal in the entire lane and graphically represented as a function of telomere length.
![]() View larger version (23K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Telomere length at the active VSG 221 ES in telomerase-deficient T. brucei. (A) (Upper panel) EcoRI telomere terminal restriction fragment hybridized with VSG 221. Progressive telomere shortening and breakage lead to loss of telomeric DNA at the active ES and smearing of the VSG 221 signal towards the bottom of the gel. (Lower panel) Reprobing with silent ES VSG bR2 verifies equal loading and progressive shortening of silent ES telomeres. (B) Signal intensity distribution in each lane of panel A is graphically represented as a function of telomere length. Smearing of the signal is apparent as peaks become broader and move towards lower molecular mass. (C) Northern blotting of VSG 221 (upper panel) and VSG 1.8 (middle panel) over 13 weeks. Positive controls for VSG 1.8 are in the right three lanes. Equal loading was verified by reprobing with a tubulin probe and ethidium bromide staining of the gel (lower panel). Phosphorimager quantification of the signal is shown in Fig. S1 in the supplemental material.
|
Long-range Southern blotting. Digestion of DNA in genomic plugs was performed as recommended by the enzyme manufacturer (New England Biolabs). Sixty units of ApaI was incubated in New England Biolabs buffer 4 plus bovine serum albumin at 25°C overnight. Plugs were subsequently washed in 0.1 M EDTA, pH 8.0, and 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.6. Restriction fragments were separated on a 0.8% agarose gel in 0.5x TBE. We used a program consisting of a 1- to 12-s linear ramp at a constant 150 V for 15 h at 12°C. The rotation angle was 120°.
Northern blotting and RT-PCR. T. brucei mRNA was isolated by using RNAstat60 according to the manufacturer's protocol. The dominant VSG expressed by the population was cloned by reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) using oligonucleotides corresponding to the T. brucei spliced leader sequence (5'-GACTAGTTTCTGTACTATAT-3') and a VSG C-terminal conserved region (5'-GACTAGTGTTAAAATATATCA-3'). PCR was carried out for 30 cycles of 1 min at 94°C, 1 min at 40°C, and 1 min at 72°C.
|
|
|---|
3-kb terminal restriction fragment contains
200 to 400 bp of telomeric repeats (15). As judged by Northern blotting, telomere lengths in this range did not affect VSG 221 mRNA levels at this time (Fig. 2B).
![]() View larger version (24K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Selection of clones with a short active ES telomere. (A) TERT-deficient (TERT/) clones cannot repair telomere truncations, and successive rounds of cloning yield clones with very short active ES terminal restriction fragments (lanes 1, 3, and 5). In wild-type populations, telomere breakage and telomerase elongation lead to heterogeneity of the VSG 221 terminal restriction fragment (WT lane). (B) (Upper panel) Northern blotting of the cells from panel A confirms that they still express VSG 221. (Lower panel) Equal loading was verified by ethidium bromide staining.
|
200 to 400 bp of telomeric DNA (Fig. 3A, upper panel) but did not shorten further. In contrast to silent ES telomeres harboring VSG bR2 and VSG V02, which continue to shorten at a rate of 3 to 6 bp/PD (Fig. 3A, middle and lower panels) and which also act as equal-loading controls, the VSG 221 signal in the active ES almost disappeared by 5 weeks (Fig. 3A, upper panel). Analysis of individual subclones revealed that some short active ES telomeres became elongated (see Fig S3A and C in the supplemental material), presumably due to repair by break-induced replication (BIR) using another telomere as a template.
![]() View larger version (31K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. A short telomere at the active ES leads to loss of the transcribed VSG. (A) VSG 221 loss in three individual TERT-deficient short active ES telomere clones (clones A, B, and C) during 9 weeks of continuous propagation. The size of the predominant VSG 221 band did not change over time, but signal intensity decreased, reflecting loss of the gene. Probes for silent ES VSG bR2 and VSG V02 (arrowheads) confirmed their stability and shortening and verified equal loading. (B) RT-PCR and Northern blotting show that VSG 224 transcripts replace VSG 221. EtBr, ethidium bromide.
|
VSG 224 replaced VSG 221 in the active expression site.
To clarify the events that led to VSG 224 expression, we generated an
9-kb SmaI terminal restriction fragment that hybridized with both VSG 221 and an upstream VSG pseudogene (Fig. 4). After 4 weeks of continuous culture, VSG 221 was again lost from the population. By week 8, the size of the predominant restriction fragments containing the pseudogene increased to
23 kb (Fig. 4A, middle panel) and colocalized with a new copy of VSG 224 (Fig. 4A, right panel), suggesting that VSG 224 and part or all of its associated telomere replaced VSG 221 at the previously transcribed ES. In addition to the
23-kb bands, a higher molecular band that does not colocalize with the pseudogene appeared (Fig. 4A). We attribute this band to individual breaks in which the SmaI site and the pseudogene marker were deleted. Deletion of the pseudogene occurred after 8 weeks in two analyzed clones, as the duplicated copy of VSG 224 appeared (Fig. 4B and C). To determine whether VSG 224 was activated by gene conversion or reciprocal translocation, we separated whole chromosomal DNA. In all three clones, VSG 221 was lost after
4 weeks and VSG 224, initially present as a single-copy gene, was duplicated into the ES that previously carried VSG 221 (Fig. 5A and C).
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Southern blotting with a unique upstream pseudogene (schematic representation on the right) demonstrates that VSG 224 replaced VSG 221 in the same active ES. (A) (Left panel) As shown in Fig. 3, the population lost VSG 221 by 8 weeks. (Middle panel) Reprobing of the blot with an ES-specific pseudogene probe. After VSG 221 loss, the size of the predominant terminal restriction fragment increases to 23 kb (asterisk). (Right panel) Reprobing with the newly expressed VSG 224 probe. VSG 224 signal appeared after VSG 221 loss and colocalized precisely with the pseudogene signal (asterisk), indicating that VSG 224 translocated into the ES, previously occupied by VSG 221. An arrowhead marks the silent copy of VSG 224. The arrow and the asterisk indicate different means of VSG 224 activation within the population (see the text). (B and C) In two other clones, the pseudogene, the SmaI site, and VSG 221 were lost (left and middle panels). The duplicated copy of VSG 224 is indicated by an arrow (right panel).
|
![]() View larger version (27K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Chromosomal DNA separation by RAGE confirms that VSG 224 replaced VSG 221 at the active ES through a duplicative gene conversion event. (A) (Upper panel) VSG 221 is lost by week 8. (Lower panel) Reprobing with VSG 224 shows that VSG 224 replaces VSG 221 on the same chromosome. Under the conditions used, the 3.2-Mb chromosome VI band, harboring the 221 ES, is well separated from other chromosomes (20, 25). The entire gel is shown in Fig. S4 in the supplemental material. +, VSG 221 positive controls. (B) (Upper panel) ES integrity was verified by the retention of the blasticidin resistance marker (BSD) that was inserted immediately downstream from the ES promoter. All three clones retained BSD and were highly resistant to blasticidin. Lanes: switch, a switched clone from a previous experiment; parental, the telomerase-deficient cell line without BSD at the active ES; WT, wild type. (Lower panel) Similarly to results shown in panel A, VSG 221 is lost after 4 weeks of continuous culture. (C) RAGE of clone A subclones after 4 and 6 weeks. Red-shaded numbers indicate subclones that lost VSG 221. Asterisks indicate subclones that lost VSG 221 but did not duplicate VSG 224. AT4 and AT6 are the 4- and 6-week populations prior to subcloning. Hybridization probes are indicated below each panel.
|
Could a short telomere trigger an antigenic switch? Due to the low switching frequency and apparent growth advantage of VSG 221-expressing cells in vitro, our cell lines rarely lose VSG 221 or otherwise result in another VSG becoming dominant in the population, even after extensive propagation. Hence, the appearance of a new VSG at the active ES locus was unexpected and could be explained in two ways. As telomere length at the active ES becomes very short, telomere breakage could lead to terminal truncations and gradual death of the VSG 221-expressing cells in the population. Switched cells, which normally arise at a low frequency, would progressively outgrow the dying cells and lead to the dominance of a new VSG in the population. Alternatively, telomere breaks could be repaired by BIR facilitated by other telomere-linked VSG, with a possible consequent increased rate of antigenic switching.
To address these questions, we attempted to measure switching frequency of strains with a very short active ES telomere by using immune selection in mice. However, due to extensive propagation in laboratory culture or unforeseen consequences of short telomeres in an animal infection that were not evident in culture, these clones did not grow well in mice. Readaptation to mice, during 3 weeks of sequential transfer, appeared to select for recombination-based elongation of the active ES telomere (data not shown).
We also made a mathematical model to predict the growth dynamics of a culture if a short telomere leads to gradual lethality and switchers arise at various frequencies (103 to 106). Gradual death of cells with a short active ES telomere and concomitant appearance of switchers (at a rate of 106, but with a growth advantage) would affect population growth dynamics only subtly over 4 to 5 weeks. In conclusion, unless the switching frequency is dramatically higher at short telomeres, switchers must have a clear growth advantage in order to outgrow the population within 4 weeks. However, we had to assume parameters, such as relative fitness of short telomere strains and growth advantage of switched parasites, for which we had no experimental data. Thus, we cannot exclude the possibility that switchers, at a frequency of 106, could have outgrown dying parasites without giving rise to a significant decline in population fitness, which would mean that telomere break-induced repair did not necessarily increase the switching rate.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. (A) Model for telomere breakage and duplicative gene conversion through BIR. (B) BIR-based elongation of deprotected short active ES telomeres.
|
106/PD could dominate the population within a period of 4 to 5 weeks without an observable pause in population growth (13, 18). It therefore remains to be determined whether short telomeres and preferential breakage at the active ES are at least partly responsible for the high rate of gene conversion-mediated antigenic variation in rapid-switching trypanosome isolates (29).
This work was supported by NIH grants AI 21729 and AI 50614.
Published ahead of print on 27 October 2006. ![]()
Supplemental material for this article may be found at http://ec.asm.org/. ![]()
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2010 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»