Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Eukaryotic Cell, April 2005, p. 673-684, Vol. 4, No. 4
1535-9778/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/EC.4.4.673-684.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Anatomy and Cell Biology,1 Department of Medicine, Royal University Hospital, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada2
Received 22 June 2004/ Accepted 21 January 2005
|
|
|---|
cac2
msi1
(caf1
) cells expressing apc5CA exhibit a phenotype more severe than that of apc5CA or caf1
. The Ts phenotypes observed in apc5CA and apc5CA caf mutants may be rooted in compromised histone metabolism, as coexpression of histones H3 and H4 suppressed the Ts defects. Synthetic genetic interactions were also observed in apc5CA asf1
cells. Furthermore, increased expression of genes encoding Asf1p, Hir1p, and Hir2p suppressed the apc5CA Ts defect in a CAF-I-dependent manner. Together, these results suggest the existence of a complex molecular mechanism controlling APC-dependent chromatin assembly. Our data suggest the APC functions with the individual CAF-I subunits, Asf1p, and the Hir1p and Hir2p proteins. However, Asf1p and an intact CAF-I complex are dispensable for CAF-I subunit suppression, whereas CAF-I is necessary for ASF1, HIR1, and HIR2 suppression of apc5CA phenotypes. We discuss the implications of our observations. |
|
|---|
The APC is a large, evolutionarily conserved complex that is essential in S. cerevisiae. The APC functions as a ubiquitin-protein ligase (E3) in the ubiquitin-dependent targeting pathway (reviewed in references 23 and 51). The E3s mark the endpoint of a molecular cascade which relies on the prior activity of a ubiquitin-activating protein (E1) and one of a family of conserved and homologous ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (E2s) (27). The E3s are structurally and functionally diverse and share the ability to select proteins for ubiquitination (65). The APC's role is to target proteins that prevent sister chromatid separation (Pds1p) and exit from mitosis (Clb2p) for proteasome-dependent degradation. The segregation of sister chromatids is sensitive to mitotic stress, and this depends in part on proper posttranslational modification of histones (11, 13). Thus, an efficient mechanism maintaining proper chromatin metabolism during mitosis may involve the coupling of sister chromatid separation with a chromatin repair, modification, and/or assembly machinery.
The chromatin assembly machinery potentially targeted by the APC would be expected to be mitosis specific, since the main function of the APC is to promote passage through mitosis. However, of all the CAFs identified, none have been shown to function exclusively during mitosis. The only CAF clearly linked to the cell cycle has been CAF-I, which is critical for S-phase-coupled nucleosome deposition (64). CAF-I is a trimeric complex conserved in virtually all eukaryotic systems studied (37, 39, 55, 64, 67). In S. cerevisiae, the CAF-I subunits are referred to as Cac1p, Cac2p, and Cac3p/Msi1p, whereas in humans the subunits are called p150, p60, and p48. Biochemical studies in vitro have shown that human CAF-I is associated with newly synthesized and acetylated histones H3 and H4 (36, 69). Furthermore, the observation that the p150 subunit of human CAF-I interacts with PCNA, a DNA polymerase clamp, sparked speculation that CAF-I is loaded onto replicating DNA via its interaction with PCNA (61, 73). Recent in vivo studies also support a role for CAF-I in S phase, as a dominant-negative p150 subunit mutation or depletion of CAF-I results in S-phase arrest with concomitant DNA damage and S-phase checkpoint activation (28, 72).
The role that CAF-I plays during S phase is not essential in S. cerevisiae, as S. cerevisiae cells lacking all three CAF-I subunits remain viable (14, 37). This may reflect redundant interactions between different CAFs. For example, yeast CAF-I has been shown to genetically and physically interact with several factors involved in chromatin metabolism, namely, Asf1p and the histone information regulators (Hir) (41, 48, 60, 66, 67). These studies revealed physical interactions between Cac2p/p60 and Asf1p and between Asf1 and the Hir proteins. Taken together, the accumulating data have lead to the suggestion that CAF-I and Asf1p/Hir proteins function in alternative chromatin assembly pathways (41). Moreover, the CAF-I p48 subunit has been isolated from plant and animal cells in CAF-I-independent complexes involved in histone acetylation and deacetylation (26, 57, 70). Although CAF-I is clearly required for S-phase-coupled chromatin assembly, CAF-I function appears to be far more complex than originally anticipated.
CAF-I has been demonstrated to function outside of S phase, as CAF-I is required for DNA repair-coupled chromatin assembly (16, 47, 49), and can assemble bulk chromatin in a replication-independent manner (35), and p60 and p150 colocalize with sites of nucleotide excision repair sites outside of S phase (42, 47). Moreover, yeast CAF-I was recently shown to be required, along with the Hir proteins, for the formation of functional kinetochores (60). Cells lacking both CAC1 and HIR1 exhibited a slow-growth phenotype due to a delay in progression through G2/M (60). Thus, it is becoming apparent that CAF-I can function outside of S phase.
In this report, we present genetic studies that suggest the existence of a complex molecular interaction between the APC and the CAF-I subunits as well as Asf1p, Hir1p, and Hir2p. The individual CAF-I subunits suppress APC defects in a CAF-I- and Asf1p-independent manner, whereas Asf1p, Hir1p, and Hir2p all require CAF-1.
|
|
|---|
::LEU2 strain, a plasmid (pPK103) containing cac1
::LEU2 and the CAC1 flanking region was obtained from P. Kaufman. A cac1
::LEU2 PCR fragment was generated by using primers designed to amplify 225 bp upstream and 1,063 bp downstream of the CAC1 coding region and pPK103 as the template. This fragment was transformed into YTH3 cells, and correct transformants were confirmed by PCR. YTH1173 was subsequently used in crossing experiments. All other strains were obtained from colleagues or generated through tetrad analyses. Strains containing msi1
::kanMX6 and cac2
::kanMX6 (Research Genetics) were selected from tetrads in which the kanMX6 marker segregated 2:2. Triple and quadruple mutants containing msi1
::kanMX6 and cac2
::kanMX6 were selected by picking spores from tetrads where the kanMX6 marker segregated 2:2 and the additional desired markers segregated with kanM6X. |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. S. cerevisiae strains
|
Standard DNA manipulations. Escherichia coli strains JM109 and DH10B were used to propagate DNA plasmids. DNA manipulations such as restriction enzyme digests, DNA minipreps, S. cerevisiae and E. coli transformations, and S. cerevisiae genomic DNA preparation have been described previously (56).
Plasmid construction. All plasmids used in this study are shown in Table 2. pTH130 was constructed by first cloning a CAC1 PCR fragment into pCR2.1-TOPO. The CAC1 PCR fragment contained 226 bp of upstream and 195 bp of downstream sequence. Both Topo-CAC1 and the S. cerevisiae 2µm expression vector, YEplac181 were digested with KpnI and PstI. The appropriate DNA fragments were ligated, resulting in plasmid pTH130 (YEp-CAC1). pRM102, which expresses histones H3 and H4 from the GAL promoter (45), was purified from RMY102.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Plasmids
|
Flow cytometry. Yeast cells were grown overnight in YPD at permissive temperatures. The next morning, cells were diluted to an OD600 of 0.2 and incubated with shaking at 30°C and 37°C till an OD600 of 0.5 was reached. The cells were then harvested and prepared for flow cytometry according to published protocols (15).
|
|
|---|
(30) and Ras2Val19 (58) phenotypes; Snf1p activates the APC (22), while Ras/protein kinase A signaling inhibits it (32, 40). Taken together, these data provide evidence that CAF-I acts downstream of the APC and, when overexpressed, may be capable of repairing damaged chromatin conferred by mutations that reduce APC activity.
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Multicopy expression of individual CAF-I subunits can restore apc5CA phenotypes. (A) Multicopy expression of CAF-I subunit genes CAC1 and MSI1 suppresses the apc5CA growth defect at 37°C. apc5CA cells (YTH1155) were transformed with YEplac181 (2µm-LEU2), YEpCAC1, YEpMSI1, and YCpAPC5. The YCp vector is CEN-ARS based. The transformants were grown for 3 to 5 days on selective medium at 30°C and 37°C. (B) Multicopy expression of CAC1 or MSI1 suppresses the apc5CA in vitro chromatin assembly defect. The transformants described above were assayed for in vitro chromatin assembly according to published protocols (20, 21). The position of uniquely labeled, circular, relaxed pBlueScript plasmid (O, R) is indicated. Efficient chromatin assembly is observed when the amount of highly supercoiled topoisomers (sup.) greatly exceeds that of the intermediate topoisomers (inter.).
|
![]() View larger version (70K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. CAF-I mutations interact genetically with the apc5CA allele. Progressive disruption of CAF-I subunits in apc5CA cells exacerbates the apc5CA Ts defect. YTH6 (WT), YTH1155 (apc5CA), YTH1537 (cac1 ), YTH1562 (cac1 msi1 ), YTH1417 (cac1 cac2 msi1 [caf1 ]), YTH1536 (cac1 apc5CA), YTH1561 (cac1 msi1 apc5CA), and YTH1418 (caf1 apc5CA) were grown overnight in YPD medium and spot diluted the next day onto the plates shown and grown at the temperatures indicated for 3 to 5 days. The plates were also grown at 16°C, but no differences were observed (data not shown). Following the incubations, the plates were scanned.
|
![]() View larger version (60K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Suppression of apc5CA growth defects by multicopy expression of CAF-I subunits is CAF-I independent. (A) YTH1296 (cac1 apc5CA), (B) YTH1275 (cac2 apc5CA), and (C) YTH1298 (msi1 apc5CA) cells were transformed with YCplac111, YCpAPC5, YEpCAC1, or YEpMSI1. The transformants were then struck out on SD-leu plates and grown at 30°C and 37°C for 3 to 5 days.
|
![]() View larger version (37K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 8. HIR1 and HIR2 suppress apc5CA Ts defects in a CAF-I-dependent manner. (A) YTH457 (apc5CA) was transformed with YCp50 and YEpHIR1. (B) YTH1637 (apc5CA) cells were transformed with YCp50, YCp50-APC5, and YEpHIR2. The transformants were grown for 3 days at 30°C and 37°C. The plates were then scanned. (C) Suppression of apc5CA Ts defects by ASF1, HIR1, and HIR2 requires an intact CAF-I. apc5CA caf1 (YTH1418) cells were transformed with the plasmids shown. The transformants were grown at 30°C and 37°C for 3 days.
|
cells also have little trouble with cell cycle progression. Thus, the increased exacerbation of the apc5CA Ts defect as CAF-I subunits are progressively deleted (Fig. 2B) is apparently not accompanied by an increased accumulation of apc5CA cells in G2/M.
![]() View larger version (22K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. CAF-I mutations do not exacerbate apc5CA cell cycle defects. Cells from the strains indicated were analyzed by flow cytometry. Cells were grown overnight, diluted back to an OD600 of 0.2, and then grown at 30°C and 37°C until an OD600 of 0.5 was reached. The strains used were YTH1636 (WT), YTH1637 (apc5CA), YTH1594 (cac1 ), YTH1817 (caf1 ), YTH1589 (apc5CA cac1 ), YTH1561 (apc5CA cac1 msi1 ), and YTH1588 (apc5CA caf1 ).
|
We next asked whether we could suppress the apc5CA in vitro chromatin assembly defect with the addition of exogenous histones. Acid-extracted histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4, obtained from untreated or colcemid-treated HeLa cells (Upstate), were added to chromatin assembly reactions with wild-type or apc5CA extracts. Histones isolated from colcemid-treated cells are rich in mitosis-specific histones. However, although addition of histones to wild-type extracts improved chromatin assembly, no effect was observed when histones were added to apc5CA extracts (Fig. 5B). It is likely that apc5CA extracts are "dead end" extracts, as we were previously unable to restore assembly activity when Apc5p protein was added back to apc5CA extracts (data not shown).
![]() View larger version (58K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Increased levels of histones H3 and H4 in apc5CA cells suppresses in vivo but not in vitro phenotypes. (A) Suppression of in vivo apc5CA Ts defects by increased expression of H3 and H4. Wild-type (YTH1636), apc5CA (YTH1637), cac1 (YTH1594), apc5CA cac1 (YTH1589), and apc5CA caf1 (YTH1588) cells were transformed with YCp50 and pRM102, which expresses H3 and H4 under the control of the GAL promoter, and grown on either galactose- or glucose-supplemented medium at 30°C and 37°C. (B) Addition of exogenous histones to apc5CA extracts does not restore chromatin assembly activity. Chromatin assembly reactions using 200 µg of wild-type (YTH5) and apc5CA (YTH1155) extracts were performed with a nonradioactive method (21). Acid-extracted histones obtained from untreated and colcemid-treated HeLa cells (Upstate) were added to the reactions in the amounts shown. Untreated extracts were included as controls; 150 µg of relaxed plasmid was used in each reaction, and the reactions were incubated at 30°C for 90 min. The ethidium bromide-stained gel was photographed and scanned, and the inverse image is shown.
|
interacts genetically with additional APC mutations.
Our data thus far indicate that at least apc5CA interacts genetically with the CAF-I subunit genes. Next, we asked whether CAF-I interactions were limited to Apc5p. We extended our analysis by creating apc10
cac1
and cac1
cdc26
double mutants. The double mutants were grown on glucose-supplemented medium at different temperatures and compared with wild-type and single-mutant cells. The results in Fig. 6 demonstrate that the disruption of CAC1 in apc10
and cdc26
cells lowers the restrictive temperature at which these mutants will grow. Thus, our results indicate the APC complex, not just Apc5p, is required for interactions with CAF-I subunits, as the cac1
mutation exacerbates the Ts growth phenotype of multiple APC mutants.
![]() View larger version (52K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. CAC1 interacts with additional genes encoding APC subunits. (A) The growth phenotypes of the apc10 mutant were compared in the presence and absence of the CAC1 gene. YTH1688 (WT), YTH1689 (cac1 ), YTH1690 (apc10 cac1 ), and YTH1691 (apc10 ) were prepared for spot dilution on glucose-supplemented medium as described for Fig. 4. (B) The growth phenotypes of the apc mutant cdc26 were compared in the presence and absence of the CAC1 gene. YTH1666 (WT), YTH1668 (cac1 ), YTH 1669 (cdc26 ), and YTH1667 (cac1 cdc26 ) were prepared for spot dilution on glucose-supplemented medium as described above.
|
cells and scored for growth at various temperatures. The apc5CA asf1
mutant grew more slowly at both 30°C and 37°C than either single mutant (Fig. 7A). This broadens the scope of APC-dependent chromatin assembly, which now appears to include Asf1p.
![]() View larger version (52K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. ASF1 interacts genetically with the apc5CA allele. (A) Disruption of ASF1 in apc5CA cells exacerbates the apc5CA Ts defect. Wild-type (YTH1156), asf1 (YTH1149), apc5CA (YTH1155), and asf1 apc5CA (YTH1159) cells were grown in liquid YPD at the indicated temperatures. At the given times, aliquots were removed and the OD600 was determined. An OD600 of 1 is approximately 2 x 107 cells/ml. (B) Increased expression of ASF1 suppresses the apc5CA Ts defect. YTH1155 cells were transformed with the plasmids shown, and the transformants were grown at either 30°C or 37°C on glucose-supplemented medium. (C) Overexpression of ASF1 but not APC5 from the CUP1 promoter suppresses asf1 apc5CA Ts growth. asf1 apc5CA cells were transformed with pYEX, pYEX-APC5, and pYEX-ASF1 and grown on SD-ura supplemented with 0.5 mM Cu(SO4)2 at 30°C and 37°C. (D) Single-copy expression of APC5 and multicopy expression of MSI1 suppresses asf1 apc5CA Ts growth. asf1 apc5CA cells were transformed with YCp50, YCp50-APC5, and YEp-MSI1 and grown on SD-ura at 30°C and 37°C. (E) Overexpression of APC5 but not ASF1 suppresses msi1 apc5CA Ts growth. msi1 apc5CA cells were transformed with pYEX, pYEX-APC5, and pYEX-ASF1 and grown on SD-ura supplemented with 0.5 mM Cu(SO4)2 at 30°C and 37°C.
|
-apc5CA genetic interactions, we tested whether increased expression of ASF1 could influence the apc5CA Ts growth defect. As expected, expression of ASF1 from the 2µm plasmid suppressed apc5CA Ts growth (Fig. 7B). We also show that overexpression of ASF1, resulting from growth of CUP1prom-ASF1-expressing cells in 0.5 mM Cu(SO4)2, was capable of suppressing apc5CA asf1
Ts growth (Fig. 7C). As in apc5CA cells (data not shown), CUP1prom-dependent overexpression of APC5 could not restore the Ts defect in apc5CA asf1
cells (Fig. 7C). This is not due to an inability of APC5 to suppress asf1
mutations, as single-copy expression of APC5 suppressed apc5CA asf1
cells (Fig. 7D). Although overexpression of APC5 in wild-type cells had no apparent effect on growth rate at 37°C (data not shown), it did reduce the replicative life span of wild-type cells (22). We interpret our observations regarding overexpression of APC5 to reflect that APC5 expression is tightly controlled in cells. Indeed, Northern analysis of APC genes demonstrated that APC4, APC5, and APC9 transcripts are extremely rare (22).
Multicopy expression of MSI1 restored the growth of the apc5CA asf1
mutant at 37°C (Fig. 7D), indicating that suppression of apc5CA Ts growth defects by MSI1 did not require Asf1p or CAF-I. ASF1 could not, however, restore the Ts defect in apc5CA msi1
cells (Fig. 7E). This observation suggests that Asf1p requires at least Msi1p to suppress apc5CA Ts defects. It is also worthy of note that overexpression of APC5 could restore the Ts growth defect of apc5CA cells when MSI1 is deleted (compare Fig. 7C with Fig. 7E). Together, these observations add strength to our hypothesis that the APC controls mitotic chromatin assembly, perhaps by recruiting multiple CAFs to mitotic chromatin templates.
HIR1 and HIR2 suppress apc5CA in a CAF-I-dependent manner.
Lastly, we asked if the interaction of APC5 with the CAF-I subunit genes and ASF1 involves an additional pair of CAF-I- and Asf1p-interacting proteins, Hir1p and Hir2p. As found for the CAF-I subunits and ASF1, the expression of HIR1 and HIR2 in multicopy suppressed the apc5CA Ts defect (Fig. 8A and 8B; HIR1 and HIR2 multicopy plasmids were kindly provided by M. Osley). Asf1p and Hir1p have been linked to a chromatin assembly pathway that functions in parallel with CAF-I (41, 59, 68). Our results agree with this hypothesis, as increased expression of ASF1, HIR1, and HIR2 could not suppress apc5CA when CAF-I subunits were deleted (Fig. 8C). We also observed that while CUP1prom-dependent overexpression of APC5 could suppress the Ts growth of an apc5CA msi1
mutant (Fig. 7E), it could not suppress the Ts growth of the apc5CA caf1
strain (Fig. 8C). Taken together, our results suggest that the APC requires only one CAF-I subunit for mitotic chromatin assembly activity, supporting a model in which the individual CAF-I subunits assemble mitotic chromatin in a CAF-I-independent manner.
The observation that all CAF-I subunits must be deleted in apc5CA cells to confer Ts growth on glycerol (Fig. 2B) provides supporting evidence for this model. The genetic complexity of this model becomes apparent when one considers that Asf1p, Hir1p, and Hir2p likely require an intact CAF-I complex to suppress apc5CA Ts defects. Thus, it remains possible that an intact CAF-I complex also contributes to APC-dependent chromatin assembly.
|
|
|---|
CAF-I subunits play a role in APC-dependent mitotic chromatin assembly. Evidence exists that potentially ties CAF-I to APC activity. For example, the smallest S. cerevisiae CAF-I subunit, Msi1p, has been found to suppress phenotypes resulting from overactive protein kinase A when expressed in multicopy (58). As protein kinase A inhibits APC activity (40), Msi1p may either play a role in activating the APC by downregulating protein kinase A, or act downstream of the APC by directly compensating for chromatin defects resulting from APC impairment. Furthermore, multicopy expression of MSI1-suppressed phenotypes associated with an SNF1 disruption (30). Snf1p is activated upon glucose limitation and acts to ensure that genes required to utilize alternate carbon sources are transcribed (9).
We recently characterized a role for Snf1p in APC activation (22). We demonstrated that Snf1p, a known aging determinant in S. cerevisiae (3, 43), was required to promote APC-dependent longevity (22). We also have evidence to suggest that protein kinase A induced life span reduction (reviewed in references 33, 44, and 63) is mediated through inhibition of the APC, as blocking Ras2p function extends apc5CA reduced life span (C. R. Geyer and T. A. A. Harkness, unpublished data). Thus, the complex MSI1 genetic interactions could be explained if Msi1p were acting downstream of the APC and was capable of repairing damaged chromatin resulting from APC inhibition through overactive protein kinase A or reduced Snf1p signaling.
The suppression of apc5CA defects by increased expression of CAF-I subunits could also be explained as an indirect effect, as each subunit of CAF-I can separately bind histones (36, 62, 69). Thus, suppression of apc5CA phenotypes could result from the compensatory action of histone binding, followed by either deposition into chromatin or sequestration. This would occur if histones were stabilized or accumulating in a free form in apc5CA cells, as excess free histones are deleterious to cell health (18). However, this is clearly not the case, as increased expression of histones H3 and H4 in apc5CA caf mutants suppressed the Ts growth defects (Fig. 5A). Even low levels of H3 and H4 expression, resulting from growth of the GAL1/10prom driven plasmid in repressing conditions (glucose), are sufficient to suppress the Ts growth defects. Our attempts to suppress the in vitro chromatin assembly defect in apc5CA extracts with the addition of purified histones demonstrated that apc5CA extracts could not be rescued by the addition of exogenous histones (Fig. 5B). We were also unable to rescue apc5CA extracts with purified Apc5p protein (data not shown). It is therefore likely that the defects conferred by the apc5CA allele are permanent once an extract is generated. We conclude from these experiments that in apc5CA and apc5CA caf cells, defects in histone metabolism can be overcome by increased expression of histones H3 and H4 in vivo.
CAF-I subunits play separate yet partially redundant functions in apc5CA cells. Our conclusion that the CAF-I subunits can function independently of an intact CAF-I complex in apc5CA cells is supported by two observations: (i) increased temperature sensitivity of apc5CA cells as additional CAF-I subunits were deleted, indicating that the individual subunits support limited viability of apc5CA cells at 37°C (Fig. 2B); and (ii) the ability of individual CAF-I subunits to suppress apc5CA Ts defects when a different CAF-I subunit was deleted (Fig. 3). Basically, if an intact CAF-I complex was interacting with the APC, then double and triple caf mutations would create the same phenotype as single caf mutations in apc5CA cells. Msi1p had previously been shown to function independently of CAF-I (34, 74). A recent study also ascribed a CAF-I-independent function for Cac1p in histone nuclear import (17). This report demonstrates additional CAF-I-independent functions for Cac1p and Msi1p and a novel CAF-I-independent function for Cac2p.
The notion that the individual subunits are at least partially redundant in apc5CA cells is based on the following observations: (i) only apc5CA cells lacking all three CAF-I subunits were Ts on glycerol, which also suggests that the CAF-I subunits provide some function that is redundant with at least Apc5p (Fig. 2B); (ii) low-level expression of histones H3 and H4 had a greater suppressive effect on apc5CA cac1
cells than on apc5CA caf1
cells (Fig. 5A); and (iii) overexpression of APC5 could suppress apc5CA msi1
cells but not apc5CA caf1
cells (compare Fig. 7E with 8C). Therefore, our results are consistent with a model in which the individual CAF-I subunits act independently and most likely redundantly with each other.
We obtained additional evidence supporting the hypothesis that the CAF-I subunits can function in the absence of an intact CAF-I complex. We performed in vitro chromatin assembly assays on extracts prepared from the mutants shown in Fig. 2B. Mild chromatin assembly defects were observed in extracts prepared from single CAF-I mutants (C. Legrand and T. A. A. Harkness, unpublished data), implying a role for intact CAF-I in mitosis-specific chromatin assembly. However, the defects were increased marginally when additional subunits were mutated, implying that CAF-I subunits may function outside of an intact CAF-I complex. Combining each CAF-I mutation with the apc5CA allele also slightly decreased assembly efficiency. The marginal defects that we observed in chromatin assembly efficiency were reproducible and consistent with the involvement of single CAF-I subunits in mitotic chromatin assembly. However, the marginal results clearly show that other factors are involved.
ASF1, HIR1, and HIR2 interact genetically with the apc5CA allele in a CAF-I-dependent manner. Work in several laboratories has demonstrated physical and genetic interactions between CAF-I, Asf1p, and the Hir proteins (38, 41, 59, 67). Asf1p has been shown to stimulate the assembly of newly replicated chromatin by CAF-I in several systems (41, 48, 59, 67) and may act by delivering histones to CAF-I in vivo (48). Consistent with Asf1p functioning as a CAF, disruption of ASF1 was recently shown to cause in vitro chromatin assembly defects (52). On the other hand, an in vivo study in S. cerevisiae suggests that Asf1p may mediate global chromatin disassembly (1). Disruption of ASF1 was shown to increase the in vivo chromatin assembly capacity of the 2µm plasmid, as opposed to disruption of CAC1, which partially reduced assembly efficiency (1).
We have been unable to observe in vitro chromatin assembly defects with asf1
extracts (data not shown). The differences observed with asf1
strains might reflect the different methods employed to measure in vitro chromatin assembly. Nonetheless, our in vivo observations are consistent with models proposing that Asf1p acts as a CAF, perhaps by facilitating the role that CAF-I plays in mitotic chromatin assembly. In the absence of intact CAF-I, however, increased ASF1 cannot suppress apc5CA defects. Perhaps under these circumstances (the absence of CAF-I), Asf1p is free to act as a chromatin disassembly factor.
Our experiments suggest that an intact CAF-I complex may play a role in mitotic chromatin assembly that is facilitated by Asf1p and the Hir proteins (Fig. 7 and 8). We have recently shown that the mitotic chromatin assembly pathway may be regulated as early as G1, as SCF (Skp1/Cdc53/F-box protein) and RSP5 ubiquitin-ligase mutants, which arrest or accumulate in G1 at restrictive temperatures, respectively, are defective in our in vitro mitotic chromatin assembly assay (2). That work also provided evidence that RSP5 interacts genetically with SCF and the APC to promote mitotic chromatin assembly.
As CAF-I is critical for replication-dependent chromatin assembly (64) and passage through S phase (28, 50), it is possible that the role that an intact CAF-I complex plays in APC-dependent chromatin assembly is limited to ensuring that cells progress through S phase. Cells must complete DNA replication and chromosome compaction in order to progress through mitosis, and this is regulated by cell cycle checkpoints that inhibit APC activity (5). Thus, our results are consistent with a model in which CAF-I assembly and disassembly are regulated at mitosis, allowing CAF-I subunits to contribute to both S-phase- and mitosis-specific chromatin assembly. There is evidence to support CAF-I disassembly in mammalian cells, as p60 is hyperphosphorylated as cells enter mitosis, and this coincides with release of CAF-I from chromatin, export of monomeric hyperphosphorylated p60 to the cytosol, and an inability of purified CAF-I to assemble chromatin in a replication-dependent manner (46).
In conclusion, the experiments presented in this report provide evidence that a novel molecular mechanism controls chromatin assembly during mitosis. It is feasible that this mechanism is in place to maintain functionally intact chromosomes during the segregation of sister chromatids or to establish a transcriptionally primed genome as cells exit mitosis. The possibility that this is a conserved mechanism raises several interesting questions. For example, what would be the consequences to a mammalian cell that harbored mutations in this pathway? We have recently demonstrated that S. cerevisiae APC is required for longevity (22). Premature aging in mammalian cells is often accompanied by cancer and genomic instability (7, 8). Strikingly, several reports have indicated that the APC plays a pivotal role in resistance to cancer (5, 53, 65). In addition, CAF-I mutations can lead to S-phase arrest and genomic instability (50, 72), while p48 and the protein that directs CAF-I to replication forks, PCNA, are deregulated in tumors found in patients with tuberous sclerosis (25). Future studies aimed at fully characterizing the mechanisms employed by the APC to control chromatin assembly in S. cerevisiae and higher eukaryotic cells will provide valuable insights into disease onset and progression.
This work was supported by grants to T.A.A.H. from the Canadian Institutes for Health Research Regional Partnership Program and the Canadian Foundation for Innovation. T.G.A. was supported by a part-time fellowship from the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research. The initial experiments were supported by grants to Mike Schultz from the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research and the Canadian Institutes for Health Research.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2010 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»