Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Eukaryotic Cell, December 2005, p. 2066-2077, Vol. 4, No. 12
1535-9778/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/EC.4.12.2066-2077.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Bessie Wanja Kebaara,
Tara Nazarenus,
Ashley Jones,
Rena Yamanaka,
Rachel Uhrenholdt,
Jason P. Wendler, and
Audrey L. Atkin*
School of Biological Sciences, University of NebraskaLincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska 68588-0666
Received 11 April 2005/ Accepted 27 September 2005
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Genome-wide transcription profiling has revealed that a significant number (estimated to be between 5 and 10%) of wild-type transcripts accumulate in yeast cells when the NMD pathway is inactivated (15, 28). These mRNAs that accumulate can be direct NMD substrates or could accumulate as an indirect consequence of inactivation of NMD. PPR1 and URA3 mRNAs represent examples of mRNAs that are directly and indirectly affected by inactivation of the NMD pathway, respectively. PPR1 mRNA is an NMD substrate because it is degraded more rapidly in cells with an active NMD pathway than those in which the NMD pathway has been inactivated (20). It encodes a transcription activator, and the genes activated by Ppr1 are up-regulated in cells with an inactive NMD pathway (18, 27). For example, URA3 is regulated by Ppr1. URA3 mRNA accumulates in cells with an inactive NMD pathway; however, URA3 mRNA has the same half-life in cells with active and inactive NMD pathways (27). Thus, accumulation of URA3 mRNA is due to increased transcription activation by Ppr1 as an indirect consequence of inactivation of the NMD pathway. To date, a limited number of natural NMD substrates have been identified. In addition to PPR1 mRNA, 12 wild-type mRNAs that are degraded by the NMD pathway have been identified (15, 20, 37, 41). Given the number of mRNAs that are affected by inactivation of the NMD pathway, it is very likely that additional wild-type mRNAs are direct NMD substrates.
The number of direct versus indirect NMD substrates in S. cerevisiae is controversial. Lelivelt and Culbertson (28) measured the half-lives of nine mRNAs whose abundance was increased in NMD mutants. None of these mRNAs has an altered half-life. This suggests that the majority of mRNAs that accumulate in NMD mutants may be indirect targets. He et al. (15) argue, on the other hand, that the majority of mRNAs that accumulate when NMD is inactivated are direct substrates. To resolve this controversy, it is important to identify direct versus indirect NMD substrates. This could be done by determining the mRNA half-lives of all of the potential NMD substrates in wild-type and NMD-deficient cells by using microarrays. However, this approach will miss low-abundance mRNAs, like PPR1 mRNA, that are below the threshold of detection (28). We have developed a complementary bioinformatics-based approach. Our approach involves using existing genomic and function databases to identify transcription factors whose mRNAs are elevated in NMD-deficient cells and the genes that they regulate. Using this strategy, we have investigated a coregulated set of genes. We have shown that NMD regulates accumulation of ADR1 mRNA, which encodes a transcription activator of genes for generation of acetyl coenzyme A (CoA) and NADH from nonfermentable substrates (42). Further, we propose that Adr1 also activates expression of ATS1.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Yeast strains used in this study
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Primer pairs used for probe DNA synthesis
|
|
|
|---|
cells.
ATS1 mRNA is one of the several hundred mRNAs that accumulate in S. cerevisiae when the NMD pathway is inactivated (28). Northern blot analysis confirmed that ATS1 mRNA levels are elevated in upf1
cells relative to an isogenic UPF1 strain (Fig. 1A). ATS1 mRNA accumulation is 1.9-fold ± 0.3-fold higher in upf1
cells than in isogenic UPF1 cells. No hybridization to RNA isolated from an ATS1
strain was seen. This strain lacks the ATS1 gene and is thus unable to synthesize ATS1 mRNA. This confirms that the correct mRNA was detected on the Northern blots. We conclude that NMD affects ATS1 mRNA accumulation.
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. The increase in ATS1 mRNA accumulation seen in upf1 yeast strains relative to UPF1 yeast strains is an indirect effect of inactivation of the NMD pathway. (A) Representative Northern blot prepared with total RNAs from W303a (ATS1 UPF1), AAY320 (ATS1 upf1 ), and AAY315 (ats1 UPF1). The Northern blots were hybridized with radiolabeled ATS1 (top), CYH2 (middle), and ScR1 (bottom) DNA probes. CYH2 and ScR1 are controls. CYH2 is a control for the NMD phenotype of the yeast strains. The CYH2 probe detects both CYH2 pre-mRNA and mRNA. CYH2 pre-mRNA is inefficiently spliced, and consequently a significant amount of this pre-mRNA is exported to the cytoplasm. CYH2 pre-mRNA has an in-frame stop codon within its intron that targets it for NMD, while CYH2 mRNA is not an NMD target (14). ScR1 is an RNA polymerase III transcript that is not degraded by NMD (29). It was used as a loading control. The relative ATS1 mRNA levels in UPF1 and upf1 yeast cells are shown below the corresponding bands in the top part of panel A. (B) Determination of ATS1 mRNA half-life by Northern blot analysis of total RNA harvested from isogenic yeast strains AAY334 (UPF1, upper image) and AAY335 (upf1 , lower image) at the indicated time points (in minutes) following arrest of transcription. Blots were hybridized with radiolabeled ATS1 DNA and PhosphorImaged. The half-lives (T1/2, minutes) are the averages of at least three independent experiments and were determined from a plot of percent mRNA remaining versus time. Percent mRNA remaining was calculated by dividing the number of pixels contained in a particular band by the number of pixels contained in the first time point. The half-life of ATS1 mRNA in each yeast strain is to the right of the PhosphorImages.
|
yeast strains (Fig. 1B). The ATS1 mRNA half-life is 10.4 ± 2.1 min in UPF1 cells and 11.6 ± 1.9 min in upf1
cells. ATS1 mRNA half-lives are not significantly different in UPF1 and upf1
strains. Therefore, ATS1 mRNA is not a direct substrate of NMD. Rather, it accumulates as an indirect consequence of inactivation of the NMD pathway. Identification of putative transcription factors that regulate ATS1 and are affected by NMD. Because ATS1 mRNA is not degraded by the yeast NMD pathway, we hypothesized that NMD affects the accumulation of an mRNA encoding an ATS1 transcription regulator. We developed a strategy to identify ATS1 transcription regulators whose mRNAs are elevated in upf mutants relative to UPF yeast cells. Our overall strategy was to (i) map putative transcription factor binding sites in the promoter region of ATS1, (ii) determine whether the putative transcription factor binding sites are conserved in closely related Saccharomyces yeast strains, (iii) identify putative transcription factors of ATS1 whose mRNAs accumulate in NMD mutants, (iv) test whether ATS1 is regulated by the candidate transcription factors, and (v) determine if the transcription factor mRNA is directly or indirectly affected by NMD.
Putative transcription factors of ATS1 were identified by analyzing the 500 bp upstream of the ATS1 ORF for putative transcription factor binding sites with the Promoter Database of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (http://rulai.cshl.edu/SCPD). There are 13 putative binding sites for nine transcription factors in the ATS1 promoter region (Fig. 2A).
![]() View larger version (53K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Potential transcription factor binding sites in the ATS1 promoter region. (A) Schematic diagram of the putative transcription factor binding sites in the 500 bp upstream of the ATS1 ORF identified with the Promoter Database of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (http://rulai.cshl.edu/SCPD). The FUN30 ORF is on the opposite strand of the ATS1 ORF, and its position relative to putative transcriptional activator binding sites is indicated. (B) Comparison of the ATS1 promoter regions from S. cerevisiae, S. paradoxus, S. mikatae, and S. bayanus. The conserved potential binding sites in the ATS1 promoter region for Adr1, Gcr1, SCB, and Gal4 are shaded.
|
40% of the S. cerevisiae transcription factors are known (26). To determine whether Adr1, Gcr1, SCB, or Gal4 might be regulated by NMD, we identified their genes and then found the average n-fold increase calculated from high-density oligonucleotide arrays for the corresponding mRNAs (Table 3; 28; http://144.92.19.47/default.htm). The average n-fold increase is a measure of mRNA levels in upf mutant strains relative to UPF yeast strains. The average GAL4 mRNA increase was 3.51-fold, indicating that this mRNA was elevated in NMD-deficient strains. The average increase in ADR1 mRNA was 1.20-fold, suggesting that this mRNA might be slightly elevated in NMD-deficient cells (Table 3). The GCR1 mRNA and the mRNAs encoding the subunits of SCB do not seem to accumulate in NMD mutants (Table 3). Further, the mRNA levels of the genes regulated by Gcr1 and SCB are similar in wild-type and NMD-deficient cells (data not shown). Gcr1 and SCB were not examined further.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Summary of potential transcription factor binding sites in the ATS1 promoter region and effect of inactivation of NMD on accumulation of their mRNAs
|
cells relative to UPF1 cells.
Steady-state ADR1 and GAL4 mRNA levels in upf1
and UPF1 yeast strains were determined by Northern blot analysis (Fig. 3). Both GAL4 and ADR1 mRNAs accumulate to higher levels in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells. Two GAL4-specific bands of 2.9 and 1.8 kb were observed on the Northern blots (Fig. 3A). These bands are specific for GAL4 because they were not present in the lane containing RNA from a gal4 deletion strain. The expected size of the GAL4 mRNA is 2.8 kb (25). Thus, the upper band is the expected size of the GAL4 mRNA and the lower band is a truncated GAL4 transcript. The lower band was not characterized further. The full-length GAL4 mRNA accumulation was 2.9-fold ± 0.2-fold higher in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells. ADR1 mRNA also accumulated to higher levels in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells (Fig. 3B). We found a 2.6-fold ± 0.2-fold higher level of ADR1 mRNA accumulation in upf1
cells compared to UPF1 cells (Fig. 3B). Thus, transcription activation of ATS1 by Gal4p and/or Adr1p could account for the increased ATS1 mRNA accumulation in upf1
cells. For this reason, we tested whether Gal4p and Adr1p regulate ATS1.
![]() View larger version (35K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. GAL4 and ADR1 mRNAs accumulate in upf1 cells relative to UPF1 cells. Representative Northern blots were prepared with total RNAs from W303a (UPF1), AAY320 (upf1 ), PJ69-4a (gal4 ), and Research Genetics strain 3573 (adr1 ). The Northern blots were hybridized with radiolabeled GAL4 or ADR1 and CYH2 and ScR1 DNAs. The relative GAL4 and ADR1 mRNA levels in UPF1 and upf1 yeast cells are shown below the corresponding bands.
|
cells.
Gal4 is a transcription activator for genes controlling the metabolism of galactose and galactose disaccharides such as lactose (reviewed in reference 6). Gal4-dependent transcription of these genes is activated by galactose and strongly repressed by glucose. Thus, we expect the mRNA levels for Gal4-regulated genes to be higher in YP-2% galactose-grown cells than in YP-2% glucose-grown cells. To test if Gal4 controls ATS1 transcription, the effects of changes in Gal4 expression on ATS1 mRNA levels were compared (Fig. 4). We determined steady-state ATS1 mRNA levels in UPF1 GAL4 and upf1
GAL4 yeast cells grown in YP-2% galactose and YP-2% glucose. Steady-state ATS1 mRNA levels were 1.0-fold ± 0.0-fold and 0.4-fold ± 0.0-fold in UPF1 GAL4 yeast cells grown in glucose- and galactose-containing media, respectively. ATS1 mRNA levels were 2.3-fold ± 0.4-fold higher in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells grown in glucose and 1.9-fold ± 0.2-fold higher in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells grown in galactose (Fig. 4). As a control, we examined GAL1 mRNA levels in cells grown in YP-2% galactose and YP-2% glucose. GAL1 is a Gal4-regulated gene (6). As expected, GAL1 mRNA was undetectable in cells grown in YP-2% glucose and readily detectable in YP-2% galactose. Thus, we conclude that ATS1 mRNA does not increase under conditions that activate Gal4.
![]() View larger version (82K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. ATS1 expression is not increased under conditions that activate Gal4p. Shown is a representative Northern blot prepared with total RNAs from W303a (UPF1) and AAY320 (upf1 ) grown in YP with 2% glucose (YP-2% glu) or 2% galactose (YP-2% gal) and from PJ69-4a (gal4 ) grown in glucose. The Northern blots were hybridized with radiolabeled ATS1, GAL1, and ScR1 probes. The relative ATS1 mRNA levels are shown below the corresponding bands in the top panel.
|
yeast strains. ATS1 mRNA accumulation was 1.0-fold ± 0.0-fold and 0.7-fold ± 0.0-fold in GAL4 and gal4
yeast strains, respectively (Fig. 4). Thus, loss of GAL4 function causes a small decrease in ATS1 expression.
Based on these results, we conclude that Gal4 is probably not a transcription activator of ATS1 because ATS1 expression is not activated under conditions that activate Gal4 and loss of Gal4 results in only a small decrease in ATS1 expression. Thus, the NMD-dependent increase in GAL4 mRNA does not account for the accumulation of ATS1 mRNA in upf1
cells. We have not examined the basis of the Upf1p-dependent increase in GAL4 mRNA further.
Adr1 may be an ATS1 transcription regulator. The potential regulation of ATS1 by Adr1p was tested in two ways. First, steady-state ATS1 mRNA levels were determined for strains differing only in their ADR1 gene copy numbers (Fig. 5A). Second, steady-state ATS1 mRNA levels were determined in yeast strains grown under conditions that repress and derepress Adr1, respectively (Fig. 5B).
![]() View larger version (41K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Adr1 may be a transcription activator of ATS1. (A) Representative Northern blot prepared with total RNA from W303a transformed with pRS314 (ADR1) and pRS314ADR1 (CEN-ADR1). The Northern blots were hybridized with radiolabeled ATS1, ADR1, and ScR1 DNA probes. (B) Representative Northern blot prepared with total RNAs from W303a (UPF1), AAY320 (upf1 ), 3575 (adr1 ), and BY4741 (ADR1). The left column of images are the result of hybridization to Northern-blotted total RNA extracted from cells cultured under repressing conditions (YP-8% glucose [YP-8% glu]). The right column has images of hybridization to Northern blotted total RNA extracted from cells cultured under derepressing conditions (YP-3% ethanol-1% D-glucose [YP-ethanol]). The Northern blots were hybridized with radiolabeled ATS1, ADH2, and ScR1 DNA probes. Adr1 is a positive regulator of ADH2, so ADH2 mRNA levels are a control for repression and derepression of Adr1. The relative mRNA levels are shown below the corresponding bands.
|
cells because they lack Adr1. The ADR1 gene copy number was increased by transforming W303a (ADR1) with an ADR1 centromeric plasmid (Fig. 5A). As a control, ADR1 mRNA accumulation was determined. ADR1 mRNA accumulation is 4.1-fold ± 0.1-fold higher in cells with additional copies of the ADR1 gene on a centromeric plasmid than in an isogenic ADR1 yeast strain which only expressed ADR1 from its normal chromosomal location (Fig. 5A). Thus, we see an increase in ADR1 expression when the ADR1 gene copy number increases. ATS1 mRNA accumulation is 4.0-fold ± 1.5-fold higher in cells transformed with the ADR1 gene on a centromeric plasmid than in an isogenic yeast strain expressing only the chromosomal copy of ADR1 (Fig. 5A). The effect of loss of Adr1 function on steady-state ATS1 mRNA levels were determined by measuring ATS1 mRNA levels in isogenic ADR1 and adr1
cells grown under Adr1-derepressing conditions (YP-3% ethanol-1% D-glucose; Fig. 5B). The relative ATS1 mRNA abundance was 0.65-fold ± 0.05-fold lower in adr1
cells than in the isogenic ADR1 cells. If Adr1 regulates ATS1, we expect ATS1 mRNA levels to be higher under conditions that derepress Adr1 and lower under conditions that repress Adr1. Sloan et al. (39) showed that Adr1 is derepressed in cells in ethanol (YP-3% ethanol-1% D-glucose) and is repressed in cells grown in high glucose (YP-8% glucose; note that standard yeast growth medium contains 2% glucose). As a control for repression and derepression of Adr1, we examined ADH2 mRNA accumulation in cells grown under derepressing and repression conditions, respectively (Fig. 5B). Adr1 positively regulates ADH2 by binding its promoter (10). ADH2 mRNA levels were difficult to detect in RNA prepared from cells grown under repressing conditions and readily detectable in RNA prepared from cells grown under derepressing conditions (Fig. 5B). The accumulation of ATS1 mRNA in ADR1 cells grown under derepressing and repressing conditions was measured by quantitative Northern blot analysis (Fig. 5B). ATS1 mRNA accumulation is 6.8-fold ± 2.0-fold higher in ADR1 cells grown under derepressing conditions than in ADR1 cells grown under repressing conditions.
Thus, ATS1 mRNA levels increase when ADR1 expression increases and when Adr1 is derepressed. ATS1 mRNA levels decrease when Adr1 is absent or when it is repressed. These results are consistent with Adr1 being a transcription activator of ATS1.
Many of the mRNAs encoded by Adr1-regulated genes may accumulate to higher levels in upf
cells than in UPF cells.
Adr1 has been shown to bind the promoters of 14 genes (42, 43). We examined the average n-fold increase calculated from high-density oligonucleotide arrays for the corresponding mRNAs (Table 4; 28, http://144.92.19.47/default.htm). Eight of the mRNAs have an average increase of 1.3-fold or greater, suggesting that these mRNA might be slightly elevated in NMD-deficient cells (Table 4). Four genes have an average increase of equal to or less than 1.15-fold. The average n-fold increase was not available for two of the genes. We confirmed that the mRNA for one Adr1-regulated gene, CTA1, accumulates by quantitative Northern blotting. CTA1 mRNA accumulation is 2.9-fold ± 0.5-fold higher in upf1
cells compared to that in UPF1 cells.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 4. Average n-fold increases in mRNAs transcribed from promoters previously shown to bind Adr1 (42)a
|
, upf2
, and upf3
yeast strains (Fig. 6A). The steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels were 2.1-fold ± 0.1-fold and 1.8-fold ± 0.4-fold higher in upf2
and upf3
yeast cells relative to those in UPF yeast cells. The increase in steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels observed in upf2
and upf3
yeast cells is similar to the increase in steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels observed in upf1
yeast cells (2.1 ± 0.4). Thus, ADR1 mRNA accumulation is dependent on Upf2p and Upf3p, as well as Upf1p.
![]() View larger version (36K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Wild-type ADR1 mRNA also accumulates in upf2 , upf3 , dcp1 , and xrn1 cells. (A) Steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels in HFY1200 (UPF1 UPF2 UPF3; wild type), HFY870 (upf1 ), HFY1300 (upf2 ), and HFY861 (upf3 ) yeast cells grown in YAPD. (B) Steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels in HFY1200 (wild type), HFY1067 (dcp1 ), and HFY1081 (xrn1 ) cells grown in YAPD. The Northern blots were prepared with total RNA and hybridized with ADR1, CYH2, and ScR1 DNA probes. The relative ADR1 mRNA levels are shown below the corresponding bands.
|
3' decay (32). Dcp1p and Xrn1p are required for decapping and 5'
3' decay, respectively (5, 32). To determine if decapping and 5'
3' decay are also required for ADR1 mRNA decay, we examined steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels in isogenic wild-type, dcp1
, and xrn1
yeast strains (Fig. 6B). Steady-state ADR1 mRNA levels were 5.2-fold ± 2.4-fold and 4.9-fold ± 2.9-fold higher in dcp1
and xrn1
cells, respectively, relative to wild-type cells. Thus, ADR1 mRNA accumulation also depends on these same decay activities because ADR1 mRNA accumulates in a decapping mutant and a 5'
3' exoribonuclease mutant. Accumulation of ADR1 mRNA following arrest of RNA polymerase II transcription. ADR1 mRNA has two features that could target this mRNA for NMD. First, the ADR1 start codon is located in a suboptimal context for initiation of translation and it is followed by an out-of-frame AUG in the optimal context at +83 with respect to the first base of the ORF. Second, ADR1 mRNA has an unusually long 3' untranslated region (UTR) (420, 590, and 810 nucleotides; 7). A suboptimal start codon context predisposes an mRNA for leaky scanning of the ribosome past the translation initiation codon. NMD is then triggered when termination occurs following initiation of translation at a downstream, out-of-frame AUG (41). The S. cerevisiae optimal start codon context is ANNAUGPuPuPu, where N is any base and Pu is an A or a G. The ADR1 start codon context is ACUAUGGCT. Further, the downstream out-of-frame AUG at +83 in the optimal context for initiation of translation. The average UTR length (5' plus 3' UTRs) of yeast mRNAs is 256 nucleotides (16). mRNAs with unusually long 3' UTRs are substrates for NMD (2, 33). Furthermore, the ADR1 3' UTR contains at least three potential downstream sequence elements (DSEs). DSEs are thought to function with premature translation termination to target mRNAs for NMD (35). Termination of translation upstream of a DSE targets an mRNA for NMD, while termination of translation downstream of a DSE does not. We hypothesized that leaky scanning and/or the unusually long ADR1 3' UTR could make this mRNA an NMD substrate.
To test the possibility that ADR1 mRNA could be a direct target of the NMD pathway, we determined ADR1 mRNA half-lives in upf1
and UPF1 yeast cells. ADR1 mRNA levels were determined following inhibition of RNA polymerase II. RNA polymerase II was inhibited by shifting rpb1-1 cells to the nonpermissive temperature or with thiolutin. rpb1-1 is a temperature-sensitive allele that encodes an RNA polymerase II subunit. As a control, we examined CYH2 pre-mRNA levels following inhibition of transcription (Fig. 7B; data not shown). Both treatments effectively arrested transcription, judging by the decrease in CYH2 pre-mRNA levels following arrest. Further, the CYH2 pre-mRNA levels decreased faster in the UPF1 cells than in the upf1
cells. This is consistent with previously published work (14).
![]() View larger version (46K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. ADR1 mRNA accumulation following arrest of transcription. Northern blots were prepared with total RNAs harvested from isogenic yeast strains AAY334 (UPF1) and AAY335 (upf1 ) at the indicated time points (minutes) after inhibition of RNA polymerase II. AAY334 and AAY335 carry rpb1-1, a temperature-sensitive allele coding for a component of RNA polymerase II. Transcription arrests rapidly in these strains when they are shifted to the nonpermissive temperature. (A, B) PhosphorImages of a representative Northern blot hybridized with radiolabeled ADR1 DNA (A) and then stripped and reprobed with radiolabeled CYH2 DNA (B). Essentially identical results were obtained in three independent experiments where transcription was arrested by a temperature shift and in one experiment in which thiolutin was used to arrest transcription. Inhibition of RNA polymerase II was effective in these experiments because CYH2 pre-mRNA levels decreased as expected following transcription arrest (B). (C) PhosphorImages of a representative Northern blot prepared with RNAs from W303a and AAY320 transformed with pKD34, which carries PGAL10-ADR1-TCYC1, and hybridized with radiolabeled ADR1 DNA. Percent mRNA remaining at each time point following inhibition of transcription was calculated by dividing the amount of probe hybridized to a particular band (corrected for loading with ScR1) by the amount of probe hybridized to the band at time zero. The percent mRNA remaining versus time after transcription inhibition was plotted with SigmaPlot.
|
cells and approximately 15 min in UPF1 cells was observed. The amount of ADR1 mRNA then decreases with time. The half-lives are 42.3 ± 12.9 and 9.3 ± 4.0 min in UPF1 and upf1
cells, respectively. Interestingly, the pattern of ADR1 mRNA levels in these experiments was independent of the method used to arrest transcription because the pattern of ADR1 mRNA levels was the same when transcription was arrested with thiolutin (data not shown). Thus, ADR1 mRNA appears to actually be degraded faster in upf1
cells than in UPF1 cells following arrest of transcription by shifting rpb1-1 cells to the nonpermissive temperature or by treatment with thiolutin.
Transient inhibition of general mRNA transcription by either genetic or chemical means induces a general stress response (12). As a part of this response, the mRNA levels for a subset of heat shock genes increase. Consistent with this, Adr1 is activated by growth in ethanol, which also induces stress responses (1). To begin to examine the basis for ADR1 mRNA accumulation in upf1
cells, we determined the half-life of ADR1 mRNA expressed from pKD34, which carries PGAL10-ADR1-TCYC1 in upf1
and UPF1 yeast cells (Fig. 7C). The half-lives of the ADR1 mRNA expressed from this construct are 3.8 ± 0.1 and 3.7 ± 0.1 min in upf1
and UPF1 yeast cells, respectively. We can eliminate leaky scanning as a mechanism for targeting ADR1 mRNA for NMD because this mRNA has the same half-life in upf1
and UPF1 yeast cells and it contains the ADR1 translation initiation codon in its native context. However, we cannot distinguish targeting of ADR1 mRNA for NMD by a long 3' UTR from an NMD-dependent change in ADR1 transcription because this mRNA lacks the long ADR1 3' UTR (PGAL10-ADR1-TCYC1 has 34 bp of sequence downstream of the ADR1 ORF, followed by the CYC1 terminator).
Overexpression of ADR1 results in respiratory impairment.
Adr1 regulates genes involved in aerobic oxidation of nonfermentable carbon sources, including lactate (42). UPF1, UPF2, and UPF3 are required for full respiratory competence (9). upf mutants have a respiratory impairment because they grow poorly on medium containing lactate as a nonfermentable carbon energy source at 18°C. This correspondence suggests that altered Adr1 expression could account for the poor growth of upf mutants on lactate-containing medium. We tested this possibility by plating yeast cells overexpressing ADR1 on CEN and 2µ plasmids. As shown in Fig. 8, W303a cells transformed with pMW5 (2µ-ADR1) grow slower on complete minimal medium lacking tryptophan and containing lactate than W303a cells transformed with pRS314. The reduced growth rate of W303a(pMW5) was specific for lactate because these transformants grew at the same rate as W303a(pRS314) on complete minimal medium lacking tryptophan and containing glucose. The reduced growth rate of W303a(pMW5) was specific for overexpression of ADR1 because lactate sensitivity was not seen in Research Genetics strain 3575 (adr1
). Interestingly, the upf1
strain (AAY320) grew as well as the isogenic UPF1 strain (W303a) in these experiments.
![]() View larger version (40K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 8. Overexpression of ADR1 causes respiratory impairment. The yeast strains used were W303a (UPF1 ADR1) transformed with pRS314 (vector control), pRS314ADR1 (CEN-ADR1), and pMW5 (2µ-ADR1); AAY320 (upf1 ) transformed with pRS314; BY4741 (ADR1); and Research Genetics strain 3575 (adr1 in BY4741). The strains were grown to an optical density at 260 nm of 0.4 to 0.6; diluted 100, 101, 102, and 103; spotted onto complete minimal medium lacking tryptophan and containing either glucose (left panel) or lactate (right panel); and incubated at 18°C.
|
|
|
|---|
Adr1 is a transcription activator, and three lines of evidence indicate that it activates expression of ATS1. (i) ATS1 has conserved Adr1 binding sites in its promoter region (Fig. 2), (ii) ATS1 mRNA levels correlate with ADR1 expression levels (Fig. 5A), and (iii) conditions that affect Adr1 activity have a corresponding effect on ATS1 mRNA levels (Fig. 5B). Our results are consistent with a global localization analysis in which intergenic microarrays were probed with DNA from chromatin bound by Adr1. Hybridization to the intergenic region of ATS1 is 1.544-fold by Adr1-bound DNA relative to background. This binding ratio may underestimate Adr1 binding to the ATS1 promoter because the putative Adr1 binding sites in the promoter region overlap the FUN30 ORF. Thus, only the Adr1-bound chromatin fragments that extend into the intergenic region between the ATS1 and FUN30 ORFs would hybridize to the DNA on the intergenic microarray. Based on our results and the results of Tachibana et al. (40), we propose that Adr1 activates ATS1 expression and that activation accounts, at least in part, for the UPF1-dependent effect on ATS1 mRNA accumulation.
Why might Adr1 regulate ATS1? In previous studies, Adr1 was shown to bind the promoters for 14 different genes involved in the generation of acetyl-CoA and NADH from nonfermentable substrates (42, 43; Table 4). We showed that Ats1p interacts with Nap1p, a cytoplasmic protein that regulates the activity of the Cdc28p/Clb2p complex (38). Based on these results, we proposed that the interaction between Ats1p and Nap1p coordinates the microtubule state with the cell cycle. Cell size changes during growth in different environments. For instance, cells grown in ethanol are larger than glucose-grown cells (24). The increase in cell size seen in ethanol-grown cells is due to a delay in the cell cycle that is partially mediated by the tyrosine kinase Swe1, a negative regulator of the Cdc28-Clb complexes (24). Since Ats1p regulates the activity of the same complex, we propose that Adr1 regulates ATS1 as part of a mechanism to coordinate the cell cycle with the metabolic status of the cell. If this is the case, we predict that changes in ATS1 expression will have an effect on cell size. Consistent with this prediction, deletion of ATS1 results in larger cells (23, 38).
Here we have shown that ADR1 mRNA accumulation is regulated by NMD (Fig. 6). The NMD-dependent regulation of ADR1 mRNA is physiologically relevant because overexpression of ADR1 mRNA may partially contribute to the respiratory impairment of upf mutants. We show that overexpression of ADR1 from a 2µ plasmid causes respiratory impairment (Fig. 8). Overexpression of ADR1 may only partially explain the respiratory impairment of upf mutants because ADR1 mRNA accumulation is 2.6-fold ± 0.2-fold in a upf1
strain (Fig. 3B) and we did not see respiratory impairment until ADR1 was overexpressed from a 2µ plasmid where ADR1 mRNA levels were elevated 9.9-fold ± 3.8-fold (data not shown). Alternatively, deletion of the upf genes in the strains used by de Pinto et al. (9) may have a more significant impact on ADR1 expression than in the W303a background. We have previously observed strain-dependent differences in the accumulation of mRNAs degraded by the NMD pathway (19). Future experiments will focus on determining whether ADR1 regulation by NMD is direct or indirect.
Our strategy complements existing microarray analyses of the effects of inactivation of NMD on global mRNA abundance in two ways. First, it allows us to sort the mRNAs affected by NMD into physiologically relevant, coregulated gene sets. Second, it uncovers low-abundance mRNAs at or below the threshold of detection on microarrays. For example, PPR1 mRNA is near the threshold of detection on microarrays (28). Our approach is applicable to other coregulated gene sets. Our strategy is limited to transcription factors with known DNA binding sites. As binding sites are identified for additional transcription factors, we expect to be able to identify additional NMD-regulated gene sets.
Several lines of evidence suggest that a role for NMD in the regulation of decay of select wild-type mRNAs is not unique to S. cerevisiae. Upf1 is essential for mammalian embryonic viability (30). NMD-deficient mouse embryos do not develop; instead, they are resorbed shortly after implantation and NMD-deficient blastocysts isolated at 3.5 days postcoitum commit apoptosis after a brief period of growth. And in Caenorhabditis elegans, NMD deficiency causes minor morphogenic abnormalities of the genitalia and reduced brood size (36). These effects probably reflect the failure both to rid the cells of mRNAs with premature termination codons and to down regulate natural substrates. As is seen in yeast, a significant percentage (4.9%) of physiologic transcripts are up-regulated mammalian cells depleted of Upf1 or Upf2 accumulate (31). A representative subset of the up-regulated transcripts with potential structural features that could cause premature termination of translation had longer half-lives in Upf1-depleted cells. Furthermore, recently Kim et al. (22) showed that mammalian Arf mRNA decay is dependent on Upf1 and Stau1, but not Upf2 or Upf3X. Stau1 binds the 3' UTR of Arf1 mRNA and reduces its abundance. This suggests at least that mammalian Upf1 also functions in decay of wild-type mRNAs that lack an apparent premature termination codon, a substrate reminiscent of the yeast PPR1 mRNA.
yeast strains than in the isogenic UPF yeast strains. We also thank Kenneth Dombek, Alan Jacobson, Phil James, Susan Wente, and Elton T. Young for yeast strains and plasmids used in this study. We are grateful to members of the Atkin laboratory for critical reading of the manuscript, helpful comments, and discussions. This work is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under grants 9874516 and 0444333.
Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this report are ours and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
R.T. and B.W.K. contributed equally to this work. ![]()
|
|
|---|
-tubulin mutations that arrest with excess microtubules. Genetics 137:381-392.[Abstract]
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»